Sunday, May 18, 2025  ·  72° Partly Cloudy NewsletterSubscribeContact
ON AIR NOW
Chicago's Morning Answer with Dan Proft  ·  Live 5–9 AM weekdays On Air Now: The Mike Gallagher Show  ·  9–11 AM Up Next: The Real Story  ·  11 AM This Afternoon: The Scott Jennings Show  ·  12–2 PM Tonight: The Larry Elder Show  ·  8–10 PM Chicago's Morning Answer with Dan Proft  ·  Live 5–9 AM weekdays On Air Now: The Mike Gallagher Show  ·  9–11 AM Up Next: The Real Story  ·  11 AM
▶  Listen Live
AM 560 The Answer - Chicago

‘They Can’t Do That’: Watchdog Journalist Documents a Statewide Pattern of Illinois Courts Sealing Public Records

By Salem Chicago News Staff

CHICAGO — Government accountability in Illinois depends heavily on whether someone is willing to file the legal motions to force it. Courts and officials across the state have developed a persistent habit of sealing public records that citizens have a legal right to see — and the ongoing corruption case in Dolton may represent the highest-profile test yet of whether that accountability ultimately lands. John Kraft, founding editor and investigative journalist with Edgar County Watchdogs — also published as Illinois Leaks — says the pattern of suppression is consistent, widespread, and costly to challenge, but the alternative is worse.

Kraft co-founded Edgar County Watchdogs in 2011 as a 501(c)(4) news-media organization based in Paris, Illinois. The Chicago Tribune profiled Kraft and his longtime collaborator Kirk Allen in 2015, describing them as “muckrakers of the farm fields” and “self-appointed guardians of taxpayer money” who comb through small-town government records in search of waste and corruption. Kraft holds memberships in Investigative Reporters and Editors, the Society of Professional Journalists, and the Chicago Headline Club. The State Policy Network awarded him the Vernon K. Krieble Unsung Hero Award in 2016, recognizing his decade-long contributions to government transparency.

The Watchdogs’ case files read like a catalog of the state’s institutional resistance to public scrutiny. A Coles County assistant state’s attorney’s mugshot was sealed. DUI records belonging to a Naperville liquor commissioner were sealed. A bank lawsuit filed in White County was sealed. Each case required the organization to file legal motions to restore public access — at its own expense. Kraft’s position on the practice is unequivocal: “Banning media [and] sealing court records is never a good option.” The standard he applies is equally direct: “If you’re going to allow one in, you can’t be selective and not allow others.” That principle, he says, holds regardless of who is doing the excluding — a point he makes with respect to Gov. Pritzker, who has criticized presidential media restrictions while previously barring certain outlets from his own press briefings. “He knew better when he did it,” Kraft says. “Now he’s trashing on the president for doing the same thing that he did.”

Kraft’s most recent reporting focuses on the Dolton corruption case, where the sentencing delays for two cooperating defendants suggest an active, larger prosecution may be taking shape. Louis Lacey, the former Dolton assistant police chief, and Keith Freeman, the village administrator, pleaded guilty to bankruptcy fraud. “Both of them ended up pleading guilty to bankruptcy fraud,” Kraft says. “They postponed his sentencing until they’re done with their investigation. They estimate it’s going to take at least another six months.”

The reason for the delay, Kraft says, is documented in the court records themselves. “I believe they’re still investigating Tiffany Henyard and that these two are cooperating,” he says. “It says right in the court records they’re cooperating.” The cooperation, he suggests, may ultimately determine how lightly both men are sentenced. “They’ll probably just get probation…cooperating, especially if they can hammer the former mayor,” Kraft says.

More of Kraft’s reporting is available at edgarcountywatchdogs.com.

Editor’s note: The following items require verification before publication: Confirm Tiffany Henyard’s status as investigation target — implied by court records but not confirmed on record; frame as “sources believe” or “court records suggest.” Confirm Freeman’s plea status independently. Verify applicable statute of limitations. Kraft refers to “Tiffany Henry” on air; the correct legal name — Tiffany Henyard — has been used throughout per editorial name-correction protocols.

Related Articles

Sue Kim on Four Underrated US Destinations

Travel author Sue Kim names San Luis Obispo, Mackinac Island, Cape May and Big Bend National Park as underrated U.S. destinations.

Lidia Bastianich on a Turkey Breast Thanksgiving

Chef and author Lidia Bastianich recommends a roasted turkey breast with apricots and bourbon for cooks watching costs. She also suggests a make-ahead baked lasagna.

Featured

Survey: Social Media Posts Sway Votes, Sprout Social Finds

Johnson Cuts Ribbon on First ‘Missing Middle’ Homes

Federal Appeals Court Holds Arguments at DePaul

Newsletter
Sign Up
Stay Connected
RSS Feed
Subscribe
CHICAGO BEARS
Own Sundays at Soldier Field.
2027 season ticket packages now available.
RESERVE YOUR SEATS ›