
By Townhall Chicago News Staff
The U.S. Supreme Court is set to hear a Second Amendment case this term challenging Illinois’ ban on semiautomatic rifles, a case a Heritage Foundation legal analyst says is likely to go against the state.
The case, Vera Montes v. Cook County, asks whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments protect the right to own an AR-15-style rifle. Illinois’ Protecting Illinois Communities Act, passed in 2023, bans the sale and ownership of many semiautomatic weapons and large-capacity magazines.
Coley Stimpson, a policy expert with the Heritage Foundation who was introduced on-air under that name, predicted the court would rule in favor of gun owners.
“Vera Montes is the big tamale that a lot of us have been waiting for,” Stimpson said. “I think almost all of us think they’re going to uphold the right to keep and possess an AR-15.”
Stimpson said he expects the court to reject Illinois’ public-safety justification for the ban. “The conservatives will bat that away like a fly at a garden party,” he said.
A ruling striking down the Illinois law could affect similar semiautomatic weapon bans in other states, though the court has not yet scheduled oral arguments or indicated how broadly it intends to rule.
Illinois Attorney General’s office has not issued a statement on the case’s potential outcome. Gun shop owners and sportsmen’s groups in the state have not yet weighed in publicly on the pending case.
The court’s term also includes cases on climate litigation preemption, excessive government fines, religious liberty in school funding disputes, and jury-size requirements, according to Stimpson, though the court has not released a final argument calendar for all of them.