
By Townhall Chicago News Staff
The Illinois Commerce Commission on Thursday approved a $40 million rate increase for Peoples Gas, slashing nearly $104 million from the Chicago utility’s request and sparing hundreds of thousands of households from a far steeper hike heading into winter.
The decision reduces what had started as a $202 million request to roughly a fifth of its original size. Peoples Gas delivers natural gas to nearly 900,000 customers in Chicago.
“The ICC’s responsibility is to balance the interests of Illinois’ utilities and their consumers, and the increase approved today reflects a fair and reasonable determination reached over the course of an 11-month legal proceeding,” ICC Chairman Doug Scott said in a statement.
Peoples Gas initially filed for a $202 million rate hike in January. Consumer advocates and Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul criticized the request as “unsupported and unexplained.” The utility lowered its ask to $144 million over the summer. ICC administrative law judges then recommended cutting the figure to $66 million. The five-member commission went further, approving roughly $40 million.
The commission also reduced the utility’s requested return on equity from 10.10 percent to 9.48 percent, up slightly from the prior rate of 9.38 percent.
Mayor Brandon Johnson and city partners praised the decision in a Nov. 20 news release, commending the ICC for reducing the proposed rate hikes.
Consumer advocates offered a mixed reaction. Sarah Moskowitz, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board, welcomed the reduction but pointed to the utility’s profits.
“The utility’s profit quest on the backs of struggling Chicagoans was especially brazen given that Peoples has recorded record earnings in seven of the last nine years,” Moskowitz said in a statement. “We hope today’s decision by the ICC is a harbinger of even stricter limits on Peoples Gas in the future.”
Abe Scarr, director of the Illinois Public Interest Research Group, said in a statement that the commission should have gone further.
“We commend the commission for significantly lowering this rate hike, but we’re disappointed they did not end the failing Peoples Gas pipe replacement program,” Scarr said. “Until the commission ends this pipe replacement program, wasteful Peoples Gas spending will burden Chicagoans with harmful pollution and excessive rate hikes.”
Much of the spending relates to the utility’s pipe retirement program, a mandate from regulators to replace more than 1,000 miles of aging iron pipes beneath Chicago’s streets by 2035. That work began about 15 years ago and has run years behind schedule and billions of dollars over budget.
Peoples Gas expressed disappointment with the ruling, saying it could halt safety-related work.
“We understand the commission today approved our continued pipe retirement plans, however today’s decision to cut $25 million in critical day-to-day safety work is surprising and extremely disappointing,” a Peoples Gas spokesperson said in a statement. “This decision ignores the recommendations of their expert staff and administrative law judges regarding this needed work.”
The Citizens Utility Board reported that nearly 20 percent of Peoples Gas’ 821,000 residential customers are more than 30 days behind on their bills, owing a total of $71.8 million.
The ICC granted the utility a record-high $306 million rate increase in 2023.
It was not immediately clear how much the approved increase will add to monthly residential bills. A $144 million hike would have added an estimated $7 to $8 to the average monthly bill, according to ICC filings. Peoples Gas said it expects to have a bill-impact estimate in the coming days. The new rates are expected to take effect in December.
Residents struggling to pay their bills can visit icc.illinois.gov/consumers/utility-energy-assistance or call 1-833-711-0374.