Sunday, May 18, 2025  ·  72° Partly Cloudy NewsletterSubscribeContact
ON AIR NOW
Chicago's Morning Answer with Dan Proft  ·  Live 5–9 AM weekdays On Air Now: The Mike Gallagher Show  ·  9–11 AM Up Next: The Real Story  ·  11 AM This Afternoon: The Scott Jennings Show  ·  12–2 PM Tonight: The Larry Elder Show  ·  8–10 PM Chicago's Morning Answer with Dan Proft  ·  Live 5–9 AM weekdays On Air Now: The Mike Gallagher Show  ·  9–11 AM Up Next: The Real Story  ·  11 AM
▶  Listen Live
AM 560 The Answer - Chicago

AMA: One insurer dominates nearly half of US metro markets

Person reviewing health insurance documents at a desk
Photo: Townhall Chicago News

By Townhall Chicago News Staff

A single health insurer controls at least half the market in 47 percent of U.S. metropolitan areas, according to a new study released Monday by the Chicago-based American Medical Association, raising concerns about competition, pricing and consumer choice.

The findings, published in the latest edition of the AMA’s annual “Competition in Health Insurance” report, show that 95 percent of the 385 metropolitan areas studied have highly concentrated commercial health insurance markets based on federal merger guidelines. The study analyzed 2025 enrollment data.

“Health insurance markets across the country remain stubbornly concentrated, limiting competition and putting consumers at risk of higher costs and fewer choices,” AMA President Willie Underwood III said in a news release. “New research confirms that insurer consolidation can drive up premiums, underscoring the real economic consequences of market power.”

Illinois ranked sixth on the list of the 10 states with the least competitive commercial health insurance markets. Market concentration in Illinois hit a 10-year peak, alongside Connecticut, Indiana, Montana, South Dakota and West Virginia, according to the study.

Nationally, the 10 largest commercial health insurers by market share were UnitedHealth Group at 15 percent, CVS (Aetna) and Elevance Health each at 12 percent, Cigna and Health Care Service Corp. each at 8 percent, and Kaiser Permanente at 6 percent, among others. Blue Cross Blue Shield insurers collectively held a combined commercial market share of 42 percent, according to the report.

In 90 percent of metro areas, at least one insurer held a commercial market share of 30 percent or greater. Blue Cross Blue Shield insurers had the largest market shares in 84 percent of metro areas.

Health Care Service Corp., which operates Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois, is headquartered in Chicago and was among the top five largest national insurers. HCSC controls the Blue Cross Blue Shield plans in Illinois, Montana, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Texas.

The study also examined Medicare Advantage markets. UnitedHealth Group held the largest market share nationally at 30 percent, followed by Humana at 17 percent and CVS (Aetna) at 12 percent. In 97 percent of metro areas, Medicare Advantage markets were highly concentrated.

The AMA noted that after the Department of Justice successfully challenged proposed mergers between Anthem and Cigna and between Aetna and Humana in 2016, large health insurers increasingly turned to vertical integration, expanding into other healthcare sectors rather than merging with direct competitors.

The report found that the largest health insurers are also the nation’s largest pharmacy benefit managers, with some extending their reach into additional healthcare markets. That growing consolidation can make it harder for physician practices to compete and remain independent, potentially limiting where patients can receive care, according to the AMA.

The average market concentration index across metro areas rose from 3,322 in 2014 to 3,409 in 2025. Excluding health insurance exchanges, the average increase was 401 points over that period, the study found.

“Strengthening competition is essential to protecting consumers and making healthcare more affordable,” Underwood said.

The AMA has published its competition study annually for 25 years, providing data to researchers, policymakers and regulators to help identify markets where mergers and acquisitions involving health insurers could harm competition.

The findings carry direct implications for the Chicago metropolitan area, where employers and residents face a market dominated by a small number of large insurers. The AMA called for continued antitrust scrutiny of health insurer consolidation and said it would continue advocating for competitive markets that protect patients and physicians.

The full report is available on the AMA’s Competition in Healthcare Research website.

Related Articles

Overnight North Side Shootings Leave 2 Dead, 1 Hurt

Two people were killed and one was critically hurt in shootings on Chicago's North Side between Wednesday night and early Thursday, according to an AM 560 newscast.

Dow Falls 1,100 Points as AI Stocks Drop Again

The Dow closed down 1,100 points Thursday as AI-related stocks fell again, according to a Fox Business report aired on AM 560. The S&P 500 fell for a sixth straight session.

Featured

Survey: Social Media Posts Sway Votes, Sprout Social Finds

Johnson Cuts Ribbon on First ‘Missing Middle’ Homes

Federal Appeals Court Holds Arguments at DePaul

Newsletter
Sign Up
Stay Connected
RSS Feed
Subscribe
CHICAGO BEARS
Own Sundays at Soldier Field.
2027 season ticket packages now available.
RESERVE YOUR SEATS ›