
By Townhall Chicago News Staff
The city of Evanston hired Thomas Kotlowski, the Crystal Lake police chief, as a private investigator to look into questions surrounding the city’s use of Motor Fuel Tax funds, according to an Illinois Answers Project report published Wednesday.
The city contracted with Clarity One Solutions LLC on June 29 to “provide investigative services,” including for “internal investigations involving public employee misconduct involving alleged policy/rule violations,” according to an agreement obtained by the Illinois Answers Project.
Kotlowski, listed as manager of Clarity One Solutions, signed the contract. He is a longtime member of the Crystal Lake Police Department and was promoted to chief in August. Public records show his company was previously registered at his home address, with his email signature listing a business address in Crystal Lake, according to the report.
Emails obtained by the Illinois Answers Project show Kotlowski communicated with city officials about Motor Fuel Tax funds multiple times. In a June 29 email to Corporation Counsel Alex Ruggie, Kotlowski said he spoke with City Manager Luke Stowe and forwarded a copy of his service agreement, according to the report. On July 23, Ruggie informed Kotlowski she would “begin pulling documents.”
In early August, Ruggie emailed Kotlowski asking him to contact First Ward Councilmember Clare Kelly to “discuss the MFT process,” according to the report. Kelly has publicly raised concerns about the city’s use of the funds. In early September, Evanston Police Chief Schenita Stewart responded to an email from Kelly, writing, “I will pass it on to the individual handling the investigation into this matter, whom you previously spoke with,” according to the report.
The agreement lists a rate of $175 an hour. The city said no invoices had been paid as of Oct. 29 in response to a records request from the Illinois Answers Project, according to the report.
An Evanston spokesperson said the city could not comment on pending investigations. The Crystal Lake Police Department did not respond to requests for comment, and Kotlowski did not return calls, according to the report.
The development comes amid broader scrutiny of Evanston’s handling of Motor Fuel Tax funds. Records show officials improperly distributed millions of dollars in road contracts for more than a decade, bypassing an Illinois law that requires municipalities to seek state authorization and advertise vendor bids in a weekly bulletin, according to the Illinois Answers Project.
The Illinois Department of Transportation reviewed Evanston’s expenditures in 2019, 2023 and again this year. By early 2026, records revealed a $20 million discrepancy between what IDOT and Evanston listed as the balance in the city’s MFT fund, according to the report.
That discrepancy caught Kelly’s attention. She began questioning the city and IDOT, which initiated another expenditures review still underway as of Oct. 16, according to the report.
The city council passed a resolution last month directing Evanston to advertise all competitively bid roadway public works projects on IDOT’s website.
“This resolution will strengthen accountability and ensure that our city follows state code which includes the required competitive bidding,” Kelly said, according to the Illinois Answers Project. “I expect us to see an improvement in our contracts and adherence to the law.”
The IDOT review of Evanston’s 2025-2026 Motor Fuel Tax expenditures remains ongoing.