
By Townhall Chicago News Staff
Goodman Theatre on Thursday announced the principal cast for the Chicago premiere of Kimberly Belflower’s “John Proctor Is the Villain,” a Tony Award-nominated play that will run Jan. 23 through Feb. 21, 2027, in the 856-seat Albert Theatre.
The production, a co-production with the Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis, will be directed by Marti Lyons in her Goodman directing debut. Lyons previously helmed the play’s 2022 world premiere at Studio Theatre in Washington, D.C.
The cast includes Mea Allen as Shelby Holcomb, Kason Chesky as Mason Adams, Isabella Star LaBlanc as Bailey Gallagher, Jack Lancaster as Lee Turner, Katherine Mallen Kupferer as Beth Powell, Felicia Oduh as Nell Shaw, Audrey Parker as Raelynn Nix, Daniel Petzold as Carter Smith and Ani Tonoyan as Ivy Watkins, according to the Goodman’s press release. Understudies will be announced at a later date.
The play is set in a small Georgia town where five young women studying Arthur Miller’s “The Crucible” in a high school English class begin to question the stories and the men they have been taught to trust. Described as fueled by pop music, optimism and fury, the production examines themes of power, blame and a generation staking its claim.
“John Proctor Is the Villain” played Broadway’s Booth Theatre in 2025 and drew seven Tony Award nominations, including Best Play, according to published reports. It has been described as the country’s most-produced play this season.
Opening night is scheduled for Feb. 1. The Goodman recommends the play for audiences ages 12 and up.
Four accessible performances are scheduled during the run: an ASL-interpreted performance on Feb. 12 at 7:30 p.m., a touch tour and audio-described matinee on Feb. 13, a performance with Spanish subtitles on Feb. 13 at 7:30 p.m. and an open-captioned performance on Feb. 14 at 2 p.m.
The creative team includes choreographer Erin Kilmurray, sound designer Melanie Chen Cole, set designer Lex Liang, lighting designer Jason Lynch and costume designer Jessica Pabst, according to published reports.
Goodman Theatre is located at 170 N. Dearborn St. in Chicago. Tickets are available through the box office at 312-443-3800.
Source: Goodman Theatre